---

Bill 9 was written to phase out Maui’s short-term vacation rentals by a future deadline. But the market is not waiting for that date to arrive. Across the island, owners, investors, and long-term renters are already recalculating what property is worth and who it is for.

In real estate, anticipation shapes markets long before policy takes effect. On Maui, this principle is unfolding in real time. The passage of Bill 9 in late 2025, which phases out short-term rentals on the historic Minatoya List, has triggered an immediate restructuring of the island’s housing market. While single-family homes remain expensive and scarce, the condominium sector is experiencing a historic surge in inventory and falling prices.

The root of this shift dates back to a 2001 legal memo by deputy corporation counsel Richard Minatoya. His opinion clarified that condos built on apartment-zoned land prior to 1989 could legally operate as short-term vacation rentals. This loophole created a lucrative market for off-island investors. However, the devastating Lahaina wildfire of August 2023 destroyed thousands of homes and displaced local families, supercharging a workforce housing crisis. Armed with new state-granted regulatory powers, Maui County enacted Bill 9 to convert these vacation units back to long-term residential use. The law sets a firm geographic timeline, ending short-term rentals in West Maui by December 31, 2028, and across the rest of the county by December 31, 2030.

As the market absorbs this regulatory shock, Maui’s real estate has split into two starkly different sectors. In the single-family home market, inventory remains frozen. Homeowners holding low interest rates from the pandemic refuse to sell and buy again at current mortgage rates of nearly 7%. This lock-in effect kept Maui’s median single-family home price at a steep $1,150,000 in July 2026.

Conversely, vacation rental owners are highly sensitive to regulatory risk and lack rate lock-in constraints. Fearing lost rental income, hundreds of investors rushed to list their properties. By late spring, active condo listings surged to more than 940 units, representing nearly 21 months of supply. This sudden deluge of listings forced a dramatic price correction. In May 2026, Maui’s median condo price dropped 21.7% year-over-year to $597,000, allowing buyers to negotiate aggressive seller concessions. These lower prices eventually drew local buyers and long-term investors back into the market. By July 2026, closed condo sales climbed over 48% year-over-year, which stabilized the median condo price at $690,000.

While local buyers welcome the price drop, economists warn of severe macroeconomic trade-offs. A study by the University of Hawaiʻi Economic Research Organization shows that while the policy could eventually return up to 6,127 units to the long-term housing stock, the contraction of the visitor industry will be painful. UHERO estimates a full phase-out will slash annual visitor spending by $900 million, cost 1,900 payroll jobs, and lead to a 4% contraction in Maui’s real GDP. Furthermore, because vacation rentals pay premium tax rates, the county faces an annual property tax shortfall of $60 million by 2029.

In response to these fiscal fears, the Maui County Council voted 7-2 on June 19, 2026, to create new H-3 and H-4 hotel zoning classifications. This legislation establishes a formal petition path, allowing eligible Minatoya List buildings to apply for hotel zoning and legally preserve their short-term rental rights. This zoning escape hatch has fractured the market. Condos likely to win H-3 or H-4 approval are retaining premium pricing, while buildings destined to remain in residential apartment zoning trade at deep discounts. Real estate transactions have become highly forensic, forcing buyers to audit individual parcels to determine their long-term regulatory fate.